Reasons

Features

  • no intent of giving responsible govt
  • brought limited self govt
  • first time proper indirect elections
  • no elected majority but first time in PLC non officers majority
    • but most non officers were nominated
  • right to vote w/ income criteria
  • first time separate electorates in ILC/PLC and local bodies
  • reservation greater than % of population for Muslim in elected seats
  • first time indian minister in Viceroy Council
  • govt can disqualify politically dangerous candidates
  • powers of viceroy as it is
  • legislatures can first time vote on individual items on budget
    • but not the whole budget (in 1892: budget discussion, but no voting)
    • supplementary questions allowed (in 1892: not allowed)
    • can pass resolutions but not binding on govt
  • SP Sinha was Indian Minister of Law

Impact

  • most short lived reforms
  • laid foundation for partition
  • benevolent despotism