Financial Bills

Money Bill	Financial Bill Type 1	Financial Bill Type 2
Article 110	Article 117(1)	Article 117(3)
Matters in 110(1)	Matters in 110(1) + other matters	Other matters + withdrawal from CFI
RS limited pwr max 14d delay & recommend changes	RS pwr same as LS	RS pwr same as LS
Prez initial recommendation	Prez initial recommendation	Prez assent for 2nd reading in both houses

Money Bill Issues

• 110(3): decision if bill is money bill not necessary
  • only needs to certify at time of transmitting bill to RS
• often govt accused of introducing ordinary bills as money bills to escape RS scrutiny
  • violates Basic Structure Doctrine, affects role of states
• RS role $\to$ revisory body; role gets defeated
• neutrality of speaker under debate
  • also refer Concerns over neutrality of Presiding Officer
• Necessary to evolve obj & independent process to arrive at correct decision
  • British system: decision by committee incl. opposition members
• Aadhar Case: Courts may check if speaker acted in arbitrary manner