• 1953: Andhra Pradesh first state formed on linguistic basis

States Reorganization Commission

  • 1954: States Reorganization Commission (Fazl Ali Commission)
    • recommended creation of linguistic state for at least for major linguistic groups
    • rejected theory of one language one state
  • 1956: reorganization of some states took place
    • Gujarat first state to be formed after this
  • 1966: Punjab and Haryana were separated from each other
  • 36th CAA 1975: make Sikkim a full fledged state
  • 84th CAA 2000: formed Jharkhand, Uttaranchal and Chhatisgarh

Arguments in favor of small states

  • decentralization of power
  • govt closer to ppl
  • easier geographical connectivity with seat of power
  • better accountability
  • solve issues related to ethnic groups, identity
  • more efficient utilization of resources
    • Jharkhand better economically than Bihar or MP

Against?

  • fears of Balkanization, internal conflicts, strong regional identity, loss of unity
  • increase in number of dispute between states over natural resources
  • resource intensive; expenditure to set up new capital, employees
  • lack of coordination dealing with national issues
    • Naxalism
    • climate change
  • states suffer due to diversion of natural resoures
    • Bihar lost its resources to Jharkhand